Waterstones: Kissing Their Customers Goodbye

Today we read the opinions of many in the trade and business press on the surprise move by James Daunt to let Amazon in to Waterstones through the front door. It is interesting to not that many state the obvious and then pull back to cover the bases just in case it’s a move that may win. Many talk about the so called capitulation over digital and hand over of that business to Amazon. Many cover the usual hypocrisy of some statements made about Amazon before Daunt’s cathartic moment when the lights came on and he became a believer.

Irrespective of all the noise, the one fact that one can’t get away from, is that Waterstones is not just handing over their digital futures in terms of sales but more importantly the very thing that drives them - their customers. It’s no surprise to be told that book readers like a mix of physical and digital and that they are often eclectic in their reading taste, but to build a strategy on retaining the physical business at the expense of the digital is at best questionable at worst naive.However, the real issue is about customers, today, tomorrow and for ever. Waterstones couldn’t tell you today who walked in their store, what they browsed, what the dithered on, what they bought and even if they had been in the store previously or bought at all in the past. Yes apart from their online business they are relatively clueless unless the customer has a loyalty card and uses it. Amazon will log,  what was bought, what wasn’t bought, what was bought with what, what was browsed, what pages were browsed and literally every aspect of the sale and every related salel. Reusing this information proactively is what the future is about and is what Waterstones is effectively handed over. They have consigned their business to mass marketing with a little direct marketing on the fringe – hardly a wise move or something any retailer should be even considering today. They may know who bought a Kindle and their first purchase but after then they may be kissing them goodbye. Is that giving the customer what they want or just naïve retailing strategy?
So the reality is that the deal is not just about digital, and online it about really knowing what your customers want and not what you think they want.



Waterstones kissing goodbye - Calm down dears!

Donmarcos's picture

I'd like to state the bleedin' obvious here - that commentators who believe they can second guess the future have about a 50-50 chance of being right at best.  If they knew so much then surely everyone would be doing what they say and then it would probably be wrong... because everyone's doing it!  Calm down dears.  Waterstones can not prevent the growth of e-books by not selling Kindles.  Neither can they prevent Amazon selling books to their customers by not selling Kindles.  So why try?  James Daunt is merely refusing to enter into childish behaviour (Amazon are taking book sales from us so we won't sell their stuff - oh please!)  

Other point:  In case these commentators hadn't noticed, Amazon are so big they hardly care what Watersones do. So Waterstones would always be the loser in any refusal to sell Amazon's stuff. Thank God JD is enough of a non-egotistical realist to see that. 

My own glass-half-full belief (hoping for the winning side of the 50-50) on e-books is that you can't hold back the tide.  E-books are here to stay and a large majority of us, like it or not, will eventually embrace them. What deadly effect will this have on our futures?  It will mean people read more.  Just like other forms of new technology there will be a bit of a craze and then a levelling out.  Hopefully Waterstone's can weather that storm.  People will still buy books made of paper.  Why?  Because they're nice.  They smell of things you remember.  You find old theatre tickets in them from that amazing play you took that girl to.  Just like 'albums' (LPs) they are real, not virtual.  But for convenience we'll all make do with e-books for our less special books or we'll have copies of both. 

Post new comment

You will need to register to comment on Futurebook.net. Register here This will take less than a minute.
By posting on this website you agree to the Bookseller Comments Policy. comments go live immediately, please be relevant, brief and definitely not abusive.
Enter your FutureBook username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <b> <i> <strong> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.